What Are the Risks of Insuring a Classic Car with Regular Insurance

Insuring a classic car with a regular auto insurance policy can expose the vehicle owner to several significant risks. Classic cars, unlike modern vehicles, often have unique value, usage patterns, and maintenance needs that standard auto insurance policies are not designed to accommodate. Below are detailed explanations of the risks associated with using regular insurance for a classic car:

1. Inadequate Valuation

Market Value vs. Agreed Value:
Standard auto insurance policies typically cover the vehicle’s actual cash value (ACV), which factors in depreciation. This method does not reflect the true market value of a classic car, which can appreciate over time due to rarity, condition, and historical significance. As a result, in the event of a total loss, the payout from a regular insurance policy may be significantly less than the car’s true worth.

Agreed Value Advantage:
Classic car insurance policies usually offer agreed value coverage, where the insurer and the owner agree on the car’s value at the outset. This agreed value remains fixed and does not depreciate, ensuring that the owner receives the full value of the car if it is stolen or destroyed.

2. Limited Coverage for Parts and Repairs

Specialized Repairs:
Classic cars often require specialized parts and services that are more expensive and harder to find than those for modern vehicles. Regular insurance policies might not cover the full cost of these specialized repairs, leading to out-of-pocket expenses for the owner.

Authentic Parts Requirement:
Owners of classic cars typically seek authentic or original parts to maintain the car’s originality and value. Regular insurance may not cover the premium cost of such parts, unlike specialized classic car insurance, which is designed to handle these unique repair needs.

 3. Restrictions on Usage

Daily Use Assumptions:
Regular auto insurance policies are based on the assumption that the car is used for daily transportation, including commuting to work and running errands. Classic cars, however, are often driven only occasionally for leisure, shows, and exhibitions. Regular policies may not account for this limited usage, potentially resulting in higher premiums that do not reflect the actual risk.

Mileage Limitations:
Specialized classic car insurance policies often come with mileage limitations that lower the risk profile and premium costs. Regular insurance lacks this consideration, leading to a mismatch between usage and coverage terms.

 4. Lack of Event Coverage

Car Shows and Events:
Classic cars are frequently displayed at car shows, exhibitions, and other events. Regular insurance policies typically do not cover damages or theft occurring during these events. Classic car insurance, on the other hand, often includes specific provisions for such scenarios, ensuring comprehensive protection.

Transport Risks:
Transporting a classic car to and from events can also pose risks that regular insurance may not cover. Specialized insurance policies often include coverage for damages incurred during transport, offering peace of mind to owners.

 5. Insufficient Storage Coverage

Storage Conditions:
Classic cars are often stored in garages or special storage facilities for extended periods. Regular auto insurance might not provide adequate coverage for damages that occur while the vehicle is in storage, such as theft, fire, or water damage.

Specialized Storage Provisions:
Classic car insurance policies typically offer enhanced coverage for vehicles in storage, protecting against a wider range of risks and ensuring the car is safeguarded during periods of inactivity.

 6. Higher Premiums

Risk Misalignment:
Because regular auto insurance does not account for the limited usage and specific risk profile of classic cars, the premiums can be disproportionately high. Classic car insurance policies, tailored to the unique needs and lower usage patterns of these vehicles, often provide more appropriate and cost-effective coverage.

 7. Claims and Settlement Issues

Claims Disputes:
In the event of a claim, disputes can arise over the value of the vehicle and the cost of repairs. Regular insurance adjusters may not have the expertise to accurately assess the value and repair needs of a classic car, potentially leading to unsatisfactory settlements.

Expertise in Handling Classic Cars:
Classic car insurers have specialized knowledge and experience in dealing with vintage and collector vehicles. They can offer more accurate valuations, appropriate repair recommendations, and better overall claims handling tailored to the unique nature of classic cars.

8. Limited Flexibility in Policy Terms

Customization Needs:
Classic car owners often need customized policy terms that reflect their specific usage, storage, and restoration needs. Regular auto insurance policies are generally standardized and may not offer the flexibility required to adequately protect a classic car.

Tailored Coverage Options:
Specialized classic car insurance policies allow for customization, including agreed value coverage, spare parts coverage, and options for occasional use, ensuring comprehensive and tailored protection.

9. Investment Protection

Financial Risks:
Classic cars can be significant financial investments, often appreciating in value. Insuring these vehicles with regular auto insurance exposes owners to financial risks if the car is underinsured or if the policy does not adequately cover the cost of repairs and restoration.

Preservation of Value:
Specialized insurance ensures that the investment is protected by providing appropriate coverage levels, reflecting the car’s true value, and offering provisions for high-quality repairs and restorations.


Insuring a classic car with regular auto insurance can leave owners vulnerable to several risks, including inadequate valuation, limited coverage for specialized repairs and parts, and higher premiums that do not reflect the car’s limited use. Additionally, regular policies may lack necessary provisions for event coverage, storage, and transport, and may not provide the flexibility and expertise required for classic cars. By opting for specialized classic car insurance, owners can ensure their vehicles are comprehensively protected, preserving both their investment and the car’s historical and sentimental value.

Leave a Comment